She's not the standard beauty but she has charms. Her expressions, words and actions all suit her. For a celebrity to grow from nothing, they can't only be pretty and have a nice body, they have to have charms to attract you.
She's definitely not your standard beauty but when she debuted, her smile was fresh and cute and when she lost her baby fat, she became more mature. And she became really pretty too. Even though it wasn't a sexy concept, she was so sexy when singing the ballad and her voice color and eye gaze were good too. Joy really looks pretty to me but people say that I got brainwashed. Even though I might be weird, Joy is cute, funny, pretty and charming to me ♥