The result of Produce X 101 not letting us know Choi Byungchan's 3rd vote ranking
We are asking Plan A Entertainment.
What is the reason for Choi Byungchan to quit the show?
(table from left to right: rank, 10th ep. ranking, 11th ep. ranking (without benefits))
1. There were 6 trainees with over 240K votes on ep. 10 (7/5 broadcast) among the 31 trainees
On ep. 11 (7/12 broadcast), there are only 5 trainees with votes over 240K among the 30 trainees
As you know, only Choi Byungchan's rank was not revealed in ep. 11.
(table from left to right: rank, vote differences ep. 10, vote differences ep.11)
2. The below are the vote differences between trainees in the same order as the above
From top 2~4
The differences in votes from 2~4 is steeper and it breaks at top 5. So we can guess that Choi Byungchan was either top 5 or top 6. (T/N: from the 1st point, it was assumed that Byungchan was in the top 6 trainees)
3-1. Let's suppose that Choi Byungchan was 6th.
On ep. 10, they revealed the votes, if we take these votes and take a daily avreage over 5 days, we can compare it to the daily vote (ep. 11 minus ep. 10) that was revealed on ep. 11. You can see that the comparison looks a bit unnatural if he was top 6. (T/N: sorry this part is confusing - basically, OP is saying that Byungchan is not top 6, since his average vote is higher than the daily vote)
3-2. Let's suppose that Choi Byungchan was 5th.
Doing the same comparison, it makes more sense if he was top 5.
So in conclusion, it is rational to think that Choi Byungchan was at most top 5 and at least top 6.
4-1. & 4-2. (estimating Choi Byungchan's votes on ep. 5 if he was top 5. He would've received 298,137)
5. Regardless of the exact number of votes he received, he could've make it to the live broadcast and he has received a considerable amount of votes.
But with a sudden report and questionable circumstance, they put a halt to his dream of debuting through Produce X 101 and to the cheers of all his fans.
We are asking Plan A
What is the reason for Choi Byungchan to be taken off the show?
If the reason for the previous announcement was correct, then what is the state of his archilles tendinitis and of his future treatments?
post response:
[+596][-9]
original post: here
1. [+114, 0]
I'm seriously not a fan of Choi Byungchan but shouldn't they at least tell us his rank? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ the fans who gathered ID's just to vote for him are turning into fools
2. [+100, 0]
Seriously, I think that all of these are based on facts. I'm a fan of another trainee but everyone should be aware of this
3. [+82, 0]
We're not asking for Choi Byungchan to be added back to the show. It's just that there are so many rumors about why he left that people are becoming more curious. No matter how pepole are asking for the truth of why he left, his company isn't saying anything. I'm seriously worried for him. There are so many stories about his leave that I'm scared it's gonna end up tarnishing him. The company is taking so much time to respond and there are so many rumors. It's such an annoying sight.
4. [+27, 0]
If MOVE won 1st, the Plan A's trainees' future might have been reversed. These issues need to be publicized. This is not only something that happened to Choi Byungchan, it could've happened to anyone else
5. [+23, 0]
OP-yah, you worked hard gathering all of this. Let's all try to uncover the truth together
0 comments:
Post a Comment