[enter-talk] WHAT'S THE STANDARD FOR A FAILED IDOL GROUP?

Seriously what are the standards for a failed idol group? I hear people mention NCT, Monsta X, Lovelyz, OMGirl,etc. as failed idols, but I seriously don't think that they're that bad?
If we look at boy groups, all groups don't necessarily have to reach EXO/BTS level.. And for girl groups, all groups don't need to be RV, Twice or Black pink.
There are so many groups in the idol market that never saw the day and disappeared..They're the groups that never made it no?

post response:

[+193][-12]

original post: here

ㅇㅇ |2018.04.23 00:26 신고하기

But on Pann, even EXO, BTS and Wanna One are failed idols

285

4

ㅇㅇ |2018.04.22 23:58 신고하기

Don't worry, on Pann, even EXO are considered a fail

244

21

ㅇㅇ |2018.04.23 03:20 신고하기

Pann only likes Bangtan, people would release tens of posts per day and they're all praising postsㅋㅋㅋ EXO and Wanna One gets dissed all the time, the more popular you are, the more hate comments you have

234

369

ㅇㅇ |2018.04.23 08:20 신고하기

Let's be real with NCT. The company is hard carrying them, even commoners have never heard of their group name

121

108

ㅇㅇ |2018.04.23 06:38 신고하기

NCT are only considered a failed because they're in SM, they debuted in 2016 and they're the male idols who have the best results among them. Even right now, their sales and results are fine

70

8

ㅇㅇ |2018.04.23 13:13 신고하기

NCT is only considered a fail because they're from SM, but they don't lose to other groups out there? Before Wanna One debuted, they were most anticipated rookies no?.. People just want to see them fail, but all their new songs got in the charts and they sold 100K copies in their first week sales, that's a fail..? EX-Bang-Wan are raising the bar high, but literally no groups except EX-Bang-Wan can produce their own scores on the chartsㅋㅋㅋㅋ If your standards are going to be like that, then all groups are considered a fail except EX-Bang-Wan

51

5